When I think about the foundational figures of the Bible, Abraham stands out as one of the most significant. His story is not just a tale of ancient times; it’s the beginning of a journey that shapes the faith and identity of millions around the world today. Understanding when Abraham was born is more than just a date on a timeline—it’s a way to connect with the broader narrative of the Bible, to place his life in the context of the unfolding story of God’s relationship with humanity.
I’ve often found that pinpointing exact dates in the Bible can be challenging. The Bible itself isn’t always concerned with giving us precise historical details; instead, it focuses on the lessons, the covenants, and the promises. However, with Abraham, we have a few clues that can help us estimate when he lived. This exploration isn’t just an academic exercise; it’s about deepening our understanding of the biblical narrative and appreciating the intricate ways in which God’s plan unfolds over time.
In this post, I’ll walk you through the clues we have from Scripture, the methods scholars use to estimate Abraham’s birth, and why this matters for our understanding of the Bible as a whole. Whether you’re a longtime student of the Bible or just beginning to explore its depths, I hope this journey through the life of Abraham will inspire and inform your faith.
Who Was Abraham?
When I think about the great figures of the Bible, Abraham often comes to mind as a cornerstone of faith. He’s more than just a historical figure; he’s the spiritual ancestor of Israel and a pivotal character in the narrative of the entire Bible. His life and faith journey provide the foundation for understanding God’s promises not just to a single family, but to all nations.
Abraham’s Significance in the Bible
Abraham’s story begins in Genesis 12, where we see God calling him to leave his homeland and journey to a place that God would show him. This call marks the beginning of a covenant relationship between God and Abraham—a covenant that includes promises of land, descendants, and blessings. The significance of this moment cannot be overstated, as it sets the stage for the entire biblical narrative that follows.
In Genesis 12:1-3, we read God’s words to Abraham (then called Abram):
“Go from your country, your people and your father’s household to the land I will show you. I will make you into a great nation, and I will bless you; I will make your name great, and you will be a blessing. I will bless those who bless you, and whoever curses you I will curse; and all peoples on earth will be blessed through you.”
This passage reveals the broad scope of God’s promise. Abraham is not just the father of the Israelite nation; through him, God intends to bless “all peoples on earth.” This universal aspect of Abraham’s covenant highlights his importance not only in Judaism but also in Christianity and Islam.
Abraham’s Role in the Broader Biblical Narrative
As I’ve studied Abraham’s life, I’ve come to see that he is the first of the patriarchs, the ancestors of the nation of Israel. His story is told across several chapters in Genesis (chapters 12-25), and it’s filled with moments of deep faith, such as when he believed God’s promise of a son in his old age or when he was willing to sacrifice his son Isaac in obedience to God’s command (Genesis 22).
But Abraham’s significance doesn’t end with his personal story. The promises God makes to him are foundational for understanding the rest of the Old Testament and the New Testament. For instance, the land promised to Abraham and his descendants becomes a central theme in the books of Exodus, Joshua, and beyond. The blessing that all nations would receive through Abraham points directly to the coming of Jesus Christ, as Paul explains in Galatians 3:8:
“Scripture foresaw that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, and announced the gospel in advance to Abraham: ‘All nations will be blessed through you.’”
Abraham’s life, therefore, is not just an isolated story but a key part of God’s unfolding plan for salvation. When I consider Abraham’s faith and the promises made to him, I see how deeply his story is woven into the fabric of the entire Bible.
Scriptural References to Abraham
To appreciate Abraham’s role, it’s essential to look at the key passages that highlight his significance. These include:
- Genesis 12:1-3: God’s initial call and promises to Abraham.
- Genesis 15:5-6: God’s promise of countless descendants.
- Genesis 17:4-5: The covenant of circumcision, where God changes Abram’s name to Abraham, meaning “father of many nations.”
- Genesis 22:16-18: The reaffirmation of God’s promises after Abraham’s test of faith with Isaac.
- Romans 4:16-17: Paul’s discussion of Abraham as the “father of us all” in the context of faith.
When I reflect on these passages, I see how Abraham’s faith journey is not just about his relationship with God, but it also lays the groundwork for the salvation history that unfolds throughout the Bible. His life is a testament to the power of faith and the far-reaching impact of God’s promises.
Biblical Clues to Abraham’s Birth
When it comes to pinpointing when Abraham was born, the Bible doesn’t give us a direct answer. Nevertheless, the Bible provides several important clues that help us piece together an estimate of his birthdate. These clues are embedded in genealogies, ages, and timelines spread throughout the early chapters of Genesis. While the exact date remains a matter of debate, these scriptural details offer us a fascinating insight into the timeframe of one of the Bible’s most pivotal figures.
Genealogies in Genesis
One of the primary sources of information about Abraham’s birth comes from the genealogies in Genesis. Specifically, Genesis 11:10-26 traces the lineage from Shem, the son of Noah, down to Terah, the father of Abraham. This passage is crucial because it not only connects Abraham to the broader narrative of the Bible but also gives us a timeline of sorts by listing the ages at which each patriarch had children.
Here’s a breakdown of the genealogy from Shem to Abraham:
- Shem had Arphaxad two years after the flood when he was 100 years old (Genesis 11:10).
- Arphaxad was 35 years old when he had Shelah (Genesis 11:12).
- Shelah was 30 years old when he had Eber (Genesis 11:14).
- Eber was 34 years old when he had Peleg (Genesis 11:16).
- Peleg was 30 years old when he had Reu (Genesis 11:18).
- Reu was 32 years old when he had Serug (Genesis 11:20).
- Serug was 30 years old when he had Nahor (Genesis 11:22).
- Nahor was 29 years old when he had Terah (Genesis 11:24).
- Terah was 70 years old when he became the father of Abram, Nahor, and Haran (Genesis 11:26).
This genealogy doesn’t just tell us about Abraham’s ancestors; it also provides a framework for estimating the timeframe in which Abraham lived. The ages listed in these verses allow us to calculate an approximate period from the time of the flood to Abraham’s birth.
Mention of Abraham’s Age
Another key clue to understanding when Abraham was born is found in the Bible’s references to his age at various points in his life. Genesis 12:4 is particularly significant because it tells us that Abraham was 75 years old when he left Haran after God called him:
“So Abram went, as the Lord had told him; and Lot went with him. Abram was seventy-five years old when he set out from Haran.”
This age is a starting point for dating his life events. To place Abraham’s birth in context, scholars often work backward from this point. If we combine this with other key events in his life, like the birth of Isaac when Abraham was 100 years old (Genesis 21:5), we start to see a more complete picture of his timeline.
The Broader Context of the Patriarchal Age
To better understand Abraham’s birth, it’s helpful to look at the broader context of the patriarchal age in which he lived. This period is often placed in the second millennium BC, a time characterized by semi-nomadic lifestyles and the emergence of early civilizations in Mesopotamia and Egypt. Scholars have used the genealogical data from Genesis, alongside external historical records, to estimate that Abraham’s birth likely occurred around the early part of this millennium.
Many scholars place Abraham’s birth around 2166 BC. This estimate is based on calculations that align the genealogical data with the broader historical and archaeological context of the ancient Near East. While this date is not definitive, it serves as a commonly accepted estimate that fits within the larger biblical narrative.
The Importance of These Clues
As I contemplate these biblical hints, I am reminded that they serve a greater purpose than just satisfying our curiosity about dates and timelines. They’re about connecting Abraham’s story to the real world—a world of ancient civilizations, migrations, and the unfolding of God’s promises over time. By piecing together these details, I find that we can appreciate the Bible’s rich historical context and see how Abraham’s life fits into God’s grand design for humanity.
Understanding when Abraham was born helps us situate his story within the broader tapestry of biblical history. It also deepens our appreciation for the intricate ways in which the Bible weaves together genealogies, ages, and events to tell the story of God’s people.
Estimating the Timeline
After exploring the biblical clues about Abraham’s birth, it becomes clear that while the Bible doesn’t provide a specific date, scholars have developed methods to estimate the timeline. As I’ve looked into these methods, I’ve found that they rely on a combination of biblical genealogies, historical context, and interpretative traditions. Estimating Abraham’s birthdate isn’t just about finding a number—it’s about understanding how his life fits into the grand narrative of the Bible and the history of the ancient Near East.
Chronological Context
To estimate when Abraham was born, it’s essential to place him within the broader chronological framework of the Bible. This framework is often built upon key events, such as the Exodus, the reigns of the kings of Israel, and the construction of the Temple in Jerusalem. By working backward from these events and using the genealogies provided in Genesis, scholars have developed a general timeline for the patriarchs, including Abraham.
One of the key chronological anchors in the Bible is the date of the Exodus. Many scholars suggest the Exodus occurred around 1446 BC, based on passages like 1 Kings 6:1, which mentions that the Exodus took place 480 years before the construction of Solomon’s Temple. If we accept this date, we can then use the genealogies in Genesis to trace the timeline back to Abraham.
Traditional Estimates of Abraham’s Birth
Most estimates for Abraham’s birth place it around 2166 BC. This date is derived from several factors:
- Genesis 12:4 states that Abraham was 75 years old when he left Haran. If we work backward from his death at 175 years (Genesis 25:7), this would place his birth 100 years earlier.
- Genesis 21:5 tells us that Abraham was 100 years old when Isaac was born. Since Isaac’s birth is a critical event in the biblical timeline, it helps to anchor Abraham’s birthdate.
- Exodus 12:40-41 mentions that the Israelites lived in Egypt for 430 years. By calculating the time from Jacob’s arrival in Egypt back to Abraham’s covenant with God, scholars can estimate Abraham’s birth within the second millennium BC.
While these estimates are not definitive, they provide a widely accepted range for when Abraham lived. This estimate places Abraham’s birth during the early part of the second millennium BC, a period marked by the emergence of powerful civilizations like Sumer, Akkad, and Egypt.
The Historical Context of Abraham’s Time
Understanding the historical context of Abraham’s time is crucial for placing his life in a broader setting. The early second millennium BC was a dynamic period in the ancient Near East. Cities like Ur (where Abraham’s journey began) were flourishing centers of culture, trade, and religion. The region was characterized by the rise and fall of city-states, the development of writing systems like cuneiform, and significant migrations of peoples.
When I consider Abraham’s journey from Ur to Haran and eventually to Canaan, I see it against this backdrop of significant cultural and social change. His story isn’t just a spiritual journey; it’s also a migration through a world that was experiencing great upheaval and transformation. The promise of land and descendants made to Abraham was given in a context where land ownership and family lineage were of immense importance.
How Scholars Arrive at These Estimates
The methods scholars use to estimate Abraham’s birthdate involve a combination of biblical chronology and archaeological evidence. They examine the genealogies in Genesis, align them with known historical events, and consider the lifespans and ages of the patriarchs as recorded in the Bible.
For instance, by correlating the ages of the patriarchs listed in Genesis with other historical events, scholars can create a rough timeline. They also consider the broader historical context of the ancient Near East, comparing biblical narratives with what is known from archaeological discoveries.
It’s important to note that these estimates are just that—estimates. They are based on the best available evidence and interpretations, but they are not absolute. Different scholars might arrive at slightly different dates depending on their assumptions and methods.
The Importance of Estimating Abraham’s Birthdate
While the exact date of Abraham’s birth might seem like a minor detail, I’ve found that it plays a significant role in how we understand the Bible’s historical reliability and its place in world history. Estimating Abraham’s birthdate helps us see the Bible not just as a collection of spiritual teachings, but as a document rooted in real historical events and timelines.
If we place Abraham within the broader history of the ancient Near East, we gain a deeper appreciation for his story and the unfolding of God’s plan through him. It reminds us that the Bible’s narrative is part of the larger story of humanity, connecting divine promises with the real-world experiences of people like Abraham.
For me, understanding the estimated timeline of Abraham’s life enhances the richness of the biblical narrative. It grounds the story of faith in a historical context, helping me to see how God’s promises to Abraham have played out across millennia, shaping the faith and lives of countless people ever since.
The Significance of Abraham’s Birth Date
Understanding when Abraham was born isn’t just a matter of historical curiosity; it holds profound theological and historical significance. As I’ve reflected on the implications of Abraham’s timeline, I’ve come to see how this information deepens our understanding of the Bible’s narrative, enriches our faith, and connects us to the broader history of the ancient world. Abraham’s birth date plays a crucial role in anchoring the biblical story in time and space, highlighting the continuity of God’s promises throughout history.
Theological Implications of Abraham’s Timeline
Abraham’s life marks the beginning of a new phase in God’s relationship with humanity. Through Abraham, God establishes a covenant that is foundational to the entire biblical narrative. This covenant is not just about promises of land and descendants; it’s about the unfolding of God’s plan for salvation and blessing for all nations.
When I think about the timing of Abraham’s birth, I’m reminded of how it aligns with God’s overarching plan. By situating Abraham’s life in the early second millennium BC, we see how God’s promises were made at a time when human civilization was developing rapidly, and new cultures and nations were emerging. This timing suggests that God’s covenant with Abraham was intended to be a light to the nations, a beacon of hope and faith in a world that was experiencing profound changes.
Moreover, Abraham’s birthdate helps us appreciate the continuity of God’s work through history. The promises made to Abraham are fulfilled in various stages throughout the Bible, from the establishment of the nation of Israel to the coming of Jesus Christ. Understanding when Abraham lived allows us to trace the fulfillment of these promises over centuries, reinforcing the faithfulness of God’s word.
Historical Considerations and Connections
As I’ve studied Abraham’s timeline, I’ve found that it also connects us to the broader history of the ancient Near East. The world in which Abraham lived was one of great complexity and change, with emerging empires, advanced city-states, and significant migrations. Placing Abraham in this historical context means we gain a better understanding of the challenges he faced and the significance of his journey.
For instance, Abraham’s departure from Ur and his journey to Canaan can be seen in light of the broader patterns of migration and settlement in the ancient world. This was a time when people were moving across regions, establishing new communities, and forming alliances. Abraham’s story is part of this larger narrative, and his faith journey mirrors the experiences of many who sought new beginnings in a changing world.
Additionally, the estimated date of Abraham’s birth helps us connect biblical events with those recorded in other ancient texts and archaeological findings. While the Bible is a unique and divinely inspired text, it is also a historical document that intersects with the histories of other ancient civilizations. If we situate Abraham within this broader historical framework, we can appreciate the Bible’s narrative as both a spiritual and historical account.
The Role of Abraham’s Birth Date in Biblical Studies
In my exploration of biblical studies, I’ve seen how Abraham’s birth date serves as a crucial reference point for scholars and theologians. It helps in constructing a chronological framework for the events of the Old Testament, allowing us to better understand the sequence and timing of key moments in biblical history.
For example, the dating of Abraham’s birth affects how we understand the timeline of subsequent events, such as the lives of Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph, the sojourn in Egypt, and the Exodus. Establishing a plausible date for Abraham’s birth means scholars can align these events within a coherent timeline, providing clarity and continuity to the biblical narrative.
Furthermore, understanding Abraham’s timeline enhances our study of biblical prophecy and fulfillment. Many of the prophecies given to Abraham, such as the promise of numerous descendants and the inheritance of the land of Canaan, are fulfilled in later generations. Knowing when Abraham lived allows us to trace the fulfillment of these prophecies and see how they connect to the larger story of God’s redemption plan.
Abraham’s Legacy and Its Enduring Impact
When I think about the significance of Abraham’s birth date, I’m struck by the enduring impact of his life and legacy. Abraham is not just a figure of the past; his faith and obedience continue to inspire believers today. The promises made to him resonate throughout the Bible, culminating in the New Testament’s portrayal of Abraham as the father of all who believe (Romans 4:16).
Abraham’s timeline reminds us that God’s work unfolds over generations. The covenant with Abraham was the beginning of a story that continues through the people of Israel, the life of Jesus, and the growth of the Christian church. With an understanding of when Abraham lived, we can see how God’s promises have been faithfully fulfilled over millennia, giving us confidence in the reliability of God’s word.
Challenges and Debates in Dating Abraham’s Birth
While the quest to determine when Abraham was born is fascinating, it’s not without its challenges. As I’ve explored the various approaches to dating Abraham’s life, I’ve encountered several areas where scholars and theologians differ in their interpretations. These debates arise from the complexities of ancient chronology, the interpretation of biblical genealogies, and the relationship between biblical narratives and historical evidence. Understanding these challenges can deepen our appreciation for the ongoing dialogue about the Bible’s historical context and how it informs our faith.
Varying Interpretations of Biblical Chronology
One of the main challenges in dating Abraham’s birth stems from the different ways scholars interpret the Bible’s chronological information. The genealogies in Genesis, which trace the lineage from Noah to Abraham, are key sources for estimating his birthdate. However, these genealogies are not always straightforward. They contain gaps, symbolic numbers, and ages that can be difficult to reconcile with known historical timelines.
For example, some scholars interpret the genealogies literally, adding up the ages of the patriarchs to calculate a specific date for Abraham’s birth. This approach, known as a “tight chronology,” often leads to an earlier date, around 2166 BC. Others, however, argue that the genealogies might be telescoped, meaning that they condense or omit generations, making it challenging to use them for precise dating. This “loose chronology” approach might place Abraham’s birth slightly later, but still within the second millennium BC.
The Role of Symbolism and Tradition
Another factor contributing to the debate is the symbolic nature of some biblical numbers. In ancient Near Eastern cultures, numbers often held symbolic meanings rather than being precise historical records. For instance, the number 40 is frequently used in the Bible to signify a period of testing or judgment, as seen in the 40 years of wandering in the desert or the 40 days of rain during the Flood. Similarly, the long lifespans of the patriarchs may carry symbolic or theological significance, rather than being strictly literal.
Thinking about this, I realize that these symbolic elements are meant to convey deeper truths about God’s interaction with humanity. While they can make historical dating more complex, they also enrich our understanding of the biblical narrative’s spiritual dimensions. The challenge, then, is balancing respect for these symbolic meanings with the desire to place biblical events within a historical timeline.
Difficulties in Aligning Biblical and Archaeological Data
Aligning the biblical account of Abraham with archaeological and historical data is another challenge that has sparked considerable debate. While the Bible provides a rich narrative of Abraham’s life, the archaeological record from the early second millennium BC is often sparse and difficult to interpret. This has led to different views on how, or even if, the events of Abraham’s life can be corroborated by external evidence.
For example, the city of Ur, where Abraham’s journey began, is a well-documented archaeological site. However, linking the specific biblical account of Abraham’s departure from Ur to the broader historical context is challenging. The Bible describes Ur as a significant city in Abraham’s time, but archaeological evidence from Ur during this period is still subject to interpretation. Similarly, identifying the exact locations of places like Haran and Canaan during Abraham’s time involves considerable speculation.
The lack of direct archaeological evidence for some of the details in Abraham’s story has led to debates among scholars. Some argue that the biblical narrative reflects a later period’s traditions, while others maintain that the story is rooted in actual historical events. For me, these debates highlight the importance of approaching the Bible with both faith and critical inquiry, understanding that the Bible’s primary purpose is theological, even as it interacts with historical realities.
Faith and Historical Inquiry: Balancing Perspectives
As I’ve navigated these challenges, I’ve realized the importance of balancing faith and historical inquiry. The Bible is a theological text first and foremost, conveying God’s revelation to humanity. While it contains historical elements, its primary focus is not on providing a precise historical record, but on communicating the truths of God’s character, covenant, and plan for salvation.
This perspective allows me to appreciate the Bible’s narrative without being overly concerned with the exact dates and historical details. At the same time, historical inquiry can enrich our understanding of the Bible by placing its stories within the broader context of ancient history. If we engage with both perspectives, we can approach the Bible with a sense of wonder and reverence, while also seeking to understand the historical realities that shaped its narrative.
The Ongoing Nature of the Debate
The debates over Abraham’s birthdate and the broader challenges of biblical chronology are ongoing. Scholars continue to explore new methods, including advances in archaeology, linguistics, and comparative ancient Near Eastern studies, to shed light on these questions. While consensus on some issues may never be reached, the discussion itself is valuable, as it encourages us to engage deeply with the Bible and the history it portrays.
The challenges and debates surrounding the dating of Abraham’s birth remind me that the study of the Bible is a dynamic and evolving field. These discussions invite us to delve deeper into the Scriptures, to explore the rich interplay between faith and history, and to appreciate the Bible’s profound theological messages. When thinking on Abraham’s life and the ongoing search to understand his timeline, I’m reminded that the ultimate significance of his story lies not in the precise dates, but in the enduring faith and covenant relationship with God that his life represents.
Conclusion
Determining when Abraham was born in the Bible is a journey that takes us through the rich tapestry of Scripture, history, and faith. As we’ve explored the clues provided in Genesis, considered the methods scholars use to estimate his birthdate, and reflected on the theological and historical significance of Abraham’s timeline, it becomes clear that Abraham’s story is far more than just a date on a timeline. It’s a testament to God’s unfolding plan for humanity, a story of faith that has inspired countless generations.
The challenges and debates surrounding Abraham’s birthdate remind us that the Bible is both a spiritual and historical document, one that invites us to explore its depths with both reverence and curiosity. While we may never pinpoint the exact year of Abraham’s birth, the insights we gain from this exploration enhance our understanding of the biblical narrative and its place in the history of the world.
I encourage you to take these insights and delve deeper into the story of Abraham. Reflect on how his faith journey mirrors our own, and consider how God’s promises to Abraham continue to resonate in our lives today. If this exploration has sparked questions or inspired thoughts, I’d love to hear from you. Please leave a comment below to share your reflections, ask questions, or engage in further discussion. Let’s continue this journey of discovery together as we seek to understand the profound impact of Abraham’s life and legacy.
Further Reading and Resources:
Books:
- Kenneth A. Mathews, Genesis 1-11:26 (New American Commentary, 1996).
This commentary provides a thorough analysis of Genesis, including genealogies, which are essential for understanding Abraham’s timeline. - Andrew E. Steinmann, From Abraham to Paul: A Biblical Chronology (2011).
This book offers a comprehensive timeline of biblical events, including the life of Abraham. Steinmann provides scholarly insight into how key biblical dates are calculated, making it an ideal resource for understanding the historical context of Abraham’s birth and life.
Articles:
- Hoffmeier, James K. “The Patriarchal Age: Abraham in History and Tradition.” 2007. Journal of Biblical Archaeology.
Hoffmeier is a credible scholar specializing in Old Testament history and archaeology. He has written extensively on the patriarchs, including Abraham, and this article examines the historical and archaeological context of Abraham’s life.
Unlock Answers to Your Top Bible Questions!
Want to deepen your understanding of the Bible? Sign up and get instant access to my FREE eBook:
"The Top 100 Bible Questions Answered" 🎉
Discover insightful, Bible-based answers to the most common questions about scripture, faith, and Christian living. Plus, get regular updates with even more valuable content straight to your inbox!
📖 Join now and start your journey to a deeper understanding of God's Word!
I think the part about Abraham’s birth date and all this estimation stuff is cool, but how do we even know for sure? Like, the evidence is all over the place, right? Still fascinating to see how historians and scholars piece things together.
Great question! You’re absolutely right—the exact birth date of Abraham isn’t clearly stated in the Bible, so scholars rely on estimates based on biblical genealogies and historical timelines. The evidence can definitely seem scattered, but it’s fascinating how historians use a mix of Scripture, ancient records, and archaeological findings to piece things together. While we may not know for sure, these estimates help us get a clearer picture of the time period and context of Abraham’s life. I’m glad you found it interesting!
That’s a good point, Eddie. But don’t you think the symbolic value outweighs the need for exact dates in religious texts?
Yes Sara, you might be right. It’s more about what it symbolizes than the exact dates.
interesting read, didnt know much about Abraham before this. good job Sam
Thank you for the kind words John.
While the examination of Abraham’s timeline is meticulously presented, one must question the reliance on traditional estimates without considering the broader archaeological context. For instance, the article overlooks the implications of recent discoveries that challenge the conventional chronology. It is fundamental to integrate all data sources to avoid a skewed understanding of ancient history.
Thank you for your insightful feedback! You raise a great point—it’s essential to consider both traditional estimates and the broader archaeological context when examining Abraham’s timeline. I agree that recent discoveries can challenge conventional chronologies, and it’s crucial to integrate all available data for a well-rounded understanding. I appreciate your suggestion and will definitely look into expanding future discussions to include these new findings to provide a more comprehensive view.
Thanks again for sharing your thoughts!
So we’re still trying to pin down Abraham’s birth date with all these vague clues, huh? Feels like shooting in the dark to me. But hey, whatever floats your boat. Not sure why it’s so crucial to nail down a specific date.
You’re absolutely right—it can feel like we’re piecing together vague clues when it comes to pinning down Abraham’s birth date! While it may seem like shooting in the dark, many scholars find it interesting to explore these timelines to better understand the broader biblical and historical context. But I get where you’re coming from—nailing down a specific date isn’t always the most crucial thing for everyone. It’s more about deepening our understanding of the world Abraham lived in. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!